quote:

Originally posted by Douglas:
[Worst Actor in a Comedy
Jim Belushi, According to Jim (ABC) 23 votes
Michael Rapaport, The War at Home (FOX) 22 votes

This is a true battle of attrition. Belushi has the edge for me since we've had to endure 6 years in total of According to Jim.

Ha ha! I corrected my mistake in the post above. Thanks for noticing the error!

quote:

Originally posted by tvfan300:

quote:

Originally posted by Douglas:
Worst Hit Show
American Idol (FOX) 21 votes
CSI: Miami (CBS) 15 votes

As much as you don't like CSI: Miami, it is the more deserving Grey's Anatomy in 2nd place with 16 votes. CSI: Miami is a distant 3rd with 9 votes.

Great Poll!!!

Keep up the good work!

64 votes in a mere 5 days! It's amazing how much passion futility can bring out!

After 64 votes, the top 2 vote-getters in each category are:

Worst Drama
Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip (NBC) 18 votes
What About Brian (ABC) 8 votes

Worst Comedy
According to Jim (ABC) 14 votes
(tie) The Winner (FOX) 12 votes
(tie) Big Day (ABC) 12 votes

Worst Hit Show
American Idol (FOX) 24 votes
Grey's Anatomy (CBS) 19 votes

Worst New Show
(tie) Big Day (ABC) 11 votes
(tie) Six Degrees (ABC) 11 votes

Worst Reality/Game Show
Armed & Famous (CBS) 15 votes
Great American Dream Vote (ABC) 13 votes

Worst Season or Series Finale
24 (FOX) 15 votes
American Idol (FOX) 11 votes

Worst Actor in a Drama
David Caruso, CSI: Miami (CBS) 30 votes
Isaiah Washington, Grey's Anatomy (ABC) and during post-Golden Globes press conference 22 votes

Worst Actor in a Comedy
Jim Belushi, According to Jim (ABC) 28 votes
Michael Rapaport, The War at Home (FOX) 26 votes

Worst Actress in a Drama
Bo Derek, Fashion House (MNT) 14 votes
Calista Flockhart, Brothers & Sisters (ABC) 13 votes

Worst Actress in a Comedy
Tia Mowry, The Game (CW) 27 votes
Sarah Chalke, Scrubs (NBC) 20 votes

Worst Reality/Game Show Host/Personality
Donald Trump, The Apprentice (NBC) 30 votes
Paula Abdul, American Idol (FOX) 13 votes

Worst Reality/Game Show Contestant
Sanjaya Malakar, American Idol (FOX) 27 votes
James "Rocky" Reid, Survivor Fiji (CBS) 10 votes

Worst TV couple
(tie) Combine any one guy and any one woman on Grey's Anatomy (ABC) 26 votes
(tie) Rob Mariano and Amber Brkich Mariano, Amazing Race: All Stars (CBS) 26 votes

Worst Supporting Actor in a Drama
Eric Dane, Grey's Anatomy (ABC) 14 votes
Dougray Scott, Desperate Housewives (ABC) 12 votes

Worst Supporting Actor in a Comedy
David Spade, Rules of Engagement (CBS) 26 votes
Oliver Hudson, Rules of Engagement (CBS) 12 votes

Worst Supporting Actress in a Drama
Kim Raver, The Nine (ABC) & 24 (FOX) 18 votes
(tie) Eva LaRue, CSI: Miami (CBS) 8 votes
(tie) Khandi Alexander, CSI: Miami (CBS) 8 votes

Worst Supporting Actress in a Comedy
Emily Rutherfurd, New Adventures of Old Christine (CBS) 17 votes
Kimberly Williams, According to Jim (ABC) 15 votes

Worst Guest Star on a Comedy/Drama/Reality Show
Ashley Ferl aka "crying girl for Sanjaya", American Idol (FOX) 17 votes
Tori Spelling, Smallville (CW) 15 votes

Lifetime Un-Achievement Award and induction into the Lemon Awards Hall of Shame
Mischa Barton, "The O.C." 31 votes
(tie) Shelley Hack, "Charlie's Angels" 7 votes
(tie) William Shatner, "Star Trek," "TJ Hooker," etc. 7 votes

Here is an idea for October/November. After all the shows have premiered for the new season, have another Lemon Award poll. Lets see what is good, and bad about the 2007-08 TV Season.

Up to a whopping 76 votes so far! Mischa Barton is the top votegetter in any category with 38 votes. And Grey's Anatomy is closing the gap on Idol for most overrated show, trailing by only 3 votes now (25 to 22).

Actually the category with American Idol and Grey's Anatomy is "Worst Hit Show" but I guess you can call them "overrated" as well!

quote:

Originally posted by tvfan300:
Up to a whopping 76 votes so far! Mischa Barton is the top votegetter in any category with 38 votes. And Grey's Anatomy is closing the gap on Idol for most overrated show, trailing by only 3 votes now (25 to 22).

Haha so true. I guess Idol already won the most overrated show "award".

quote:

Originally posted by Douglas:
Actually the category with American Idol and Grey's Anatomy is "Worst Hit Show" but I guess you can call them "overrated" as well!

quote:

Originally posted by tvfan300:
Up to a whopping 76 votes so far! Mischa Barton is the top votegetter in any category with 38 votes. And Grey's Anatomy is closing the gap on Idol for most overrated show, trailing by only 3 votes now (25 to 22).

I don't care what the results say on this one, but I have to write in Adrianna Costa as the all time worst Reality Show host. Her outfits alone should qualify her! Each week, we manage to both cringe and giggle at her mistakes and horrid attempts at hosting this show. You may hate the Donald, but at least he has successfully hosted his show.

After 83 votes, the top 2 vote-getters in each category are:

Worst Drama
Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip (NBC) 23 votes
What About Brian (ABC) 10 votes

Worst Comedy
According to Jim (ABC) 18 votes
Big Day (ABC) 17 votes

Worst Hit Show
American Idol (FOX) 28 votes
Grey's Anatomy (CBS) 22 votes

Worst New Show
Six Degrees (ABC) 16 votes
Big Day (ABC) 15 votes

Worst Reality/Game Show
Armed & Famous (CBS) 23 votes
Great American Dream Vote (ABC) 14 votes

Worst Season or Series Finale
24 (FOX) 18 votes
American Idol (FOX) 14 votes

Worst Actor in a Drama
David Caruso, CSI: Miami (CBS) 39 votes
Isaiah Washington, Grey's Anatomy (ABC) and during post-Golden Globes press conference 27 votes

Worst Actor in a Comedy
(tie) Jim Belushi, According to Jim (ABC) 34 votes
(tie) Michael Rapaport, The War at Home (FOX) 34 votes

Worst Actress in a Drama
Bo Derek, Fashion House (MNT) 20 votes
Calista Flockhart, Brothers & Sisters (ABC) 17 votes

Worst Actress in a Comedy
Tia Mowry, The Game (CW) 38 votes
Julia Louis Dreyfus, New Adventures of Old Christine (CBS) 23 votes

Worst Reality/Game Show Host/Personality
Donald Trump, The Apprentice (NBC) 40 votes
Paula Abdul, American Idol (FOX) 18 votes

Worst Reality/Game Show Contestant
Sanjaya Malakar, American Idol (FOX) 33 votes
James "Rocky" Reid, Survivor Fiji (CBS) 13 votes

Worst TV couple
(tie) Combine any one guy and any one woman on Grey's Anatomy (ABC) 32 votes
(tie) Rob Mariano and Amber Brkich Mariano, Amazing Race: All Stars (CBS) 32 votes

Worst Supporting Actor in a Drama
Eric Dane, Grey's Anatomy (ABC) 17 votes
Jonathan Togo, CSI: Miami (CBS) 16 votes

Worst Supporting Actor in a Comedy
David Spade, Rules of Engagement (CBS) 32 votes
Oliver Hudson, Rules of Engagement (CBS) 19 votes

Worst Supporting Actress in a Drama
Kim Raver, The Nine (ABC) & 24 (FOX) 23 votes
Khandi Alexander, CSI: Miami (CBS) 11 votes

Worst Supporting Actress in a Comedy
Emily Rutherfurd, New Adventures of Old Christine (CBS) 20 votes
Kimberly Williams, According to Jim (ABC) 16 votes

Worst Guest Star on a Comedy/Drama/Reality Show
Ashley Ferl aka "crying girl for Sanjaya", American Idol (FOX) 24 votes
Tori Spelling, Smallville (CW) 18 votes

Lifetime Un-Achievement Award and induction into the Lemon Awards Hall of Shame
Mischa Barton, "The O.C." 40 votes
Shelley Hack, "Charlie's Angels" 11 votes

quote:

Originally posted by Douglas:
[Worst Actor in a Comedy
Jim Belushi, According to Jim (ABC) 23 votes
Michael Rapaport, The War at Home (FOX) 22 votes

The 84th vote today has given Rapaport a 35 to 34 vote lead. This one's going right down to the wire.

This message has been edited. Last edited by: tvfan300,

Hey, folks: mark your calendars for Monday, Sept. 17 at 2 p.m. ET.

The First-Ever Live Webcast of
MR. TV’s FALL 2007 TV PREVIEW

A New Series from Mediaweek

quote:

Originally posted by xwiseguyx:
I don't care what the results say on this one, but I have to write in Adrianna Costa as the all time worst Reality Show host. Her outfits alone should qualify her! Each week, we manage to both cringe and giggle at her mistakes and horrid attempts at hosting this show. You may hate the Donald, but at least he has successfully hosted his show.

I keep wondering why Spielberg didn't host the show himself--or someone like Robert Osborne of TCM--both of them out of the demo?

And would Chelsea Handler had walked out of "On the Lot" if there wasn't an E! show seemingly waiting for her? I don't think so.

And speaking of "Chelsea Lately"--what's the deal with the Mexican midget?

Up to 89 votes now. With the 1300+ members we have here, we shout at least make it too 100.