I did this similar thing last season as a poll but this time, I'm just going to post my thoughts here instead of a poll and as the season wears on, I'm sure my list of ratings for each houseguest will fluctuate.
My ratings of the remaining residing houseguests, as of August 8, 2008 ("0" being most disliked by me; "10" being most liked by me):
Renny Martyn: 9 out of 10 The "Dah-lin' from Nu Orlin'" is still tops!
Keesha Smith: 8 It's like she's BB8's Daniele but much more healthier looking and much less disgustingly flirtatious.
Libra Thompson: 7 out of 10 She handled herself perfectly at the start of the season when she saw Brian and Ollie deciding that Memphis was going to be put up in place of Jessie. Yes, she's confrontational. Yes, she stirs the pot. But for entertainment value, she's good. She'd be even great if she played to the TV audience, as did BB3's Danielle Reyes ("Roddy is the Devil!" & her weekly "__ down, __ to go" phrases). And it should be no surprise of this view of mine - I was in the pro-Evel Dick camp last summer. Now, I hope she makes her enemies' lives a living hell the next week.
Dan Gheesling: 7 out of 10 Thankfully, he isn't the preachy type of person he portrayed to be in his introductory profile piece from the premiere. But his rating would've been higher if not for his cornyness.
Michelle Costa: 6 out of 10 With Jessie gone, she moves up in my book! And that red unitard not only accentuated her body but my rating for her as well.
Memphis Garrett: 5 out of 10 Now without the wrath of a-hole Jessie Godderz out of the way, he too moves up in my book! Still, he's a bore to watch, and will conveniently fly under the radar this week so forget about him providing any added entertainment.
And now for the complete duds:
Jerry MacDonald: 3 out of 10 Who woulda thunk it? I actually didn't mind his "womanizing" rant against Memphis at the time but since his role on BB10 is becoming increasingly futile yet has the nerve to shout "glad you're going home" to Libra's face last night, I'm finding that I've had it with him. The person with the worst sounding voice in the house loves to shout and rant. Clear your darn throat, you geezer!
April Dowling: 1 out of 10 Keesha may be whiny but April is even more whiny and way more annoyingly sneaky.
Bryan Ollie aka "Ollie": 0 out of 10 Everything April says, Ollie says. Everything April does, Ollie does. Ollie will always be behind April... in more ways than one (check YouTube)!
This message has been edited. Last edited by: Douglas,
Love: 9.Libra: 9/10 I like Renny more, but Libra makes the show much more interesting. I'm sad her four week reign as HOH is coming to an end. 8.Renny: 8/10 She is so funny. I loved the way she told Jerry off on Tuesday night.
Like: 7.Dan: 6/10 I like him, but he's not the most interesting houseguest. His hug with Jessie was great. 6.Memphis: 6/10 Defenitely in the best position in the house. Brian was right when he said he could win this. 5.Keesha: 5/10 Sometimes she does something I can't stand, but most of the time I like her. Her laugh is the best part about her.
Dislike: 4.Michelle: 3/10 Will probably go down in my book a lot this week with the nominations it looks like she is going to make.
Unbearable: 3.April: 1/10 A disgusting person. 2.Ollie: 0/10 April's second vote. 1.Jerry: -1/10 Words can't describe how bad he is.
Posts: 1809 | Location: New Jersey | Registered: 24 March 2007
Michelle - 9 out of 10: Oh you look saucy in that unitard. Now that ego-maniac Jessie is no longer by your side, go kick some butt!
Renny - 8.5 out of 10: I just love the accent. Yeah, she was initially my least favorite, but so what? Sayonara, Jessie, and Jerry, get your friggin' finger out of my face!
Libra - 8 out of 10: So 1 extra point for being from the Metro-Houston area. What makes Michelle's HoH victory all the greater is that now it's time for Libra to go Evel Dick on the house. Her screaming at somebody and them screaming back is just pure harmony. Maybe she can team up with Keesha for a reincarnation of Journey's "Who's Cryin' Now" this week.
In the Middle:
Dan - 7 out of 10: I'm kinda indifferent here...his post-week 1 strategy of laying low was working wonders until he became America's Player. He's kinda dull on the whole but he's not, say, Jerry.
Memphis - 6 out of 10: Definite physical threat and now that he has loudmouth Libra and Keesha in his alliance he's bound to fly under the radar. And I'm guessing he might need a million bucks since I've yet to find an academic institution that hands out a degree in "Mixology".
Bottom of the Barrel:
April - 4 out of 10: Whiny voice, hot as hell, somewhat fake, and seems to flip-flop on her alliance every week.
Ollie - 3 out of 10: Yes, April, that sounds great. Seriously dude, distinguish yourself.
Keesha - 2 out of 10: Everything below the chin is a 10. Everything above it, well I guess that's a negative 6. Everytime I here her whiny voice I thank the powers that be the television came with a mute button.
Jerry - 1 out of 10: Does he have to run around and tell everybody their fate? He told Jessie "It's Done." He told Libra "You're Going Home". And that old creeky voice is just maddening. Please, give it a rest and go take a nap already.
Originally posted by xwiseguyx: 1. Michelle. Sorry but my least favorite. When she called Libra a skank, whore etc... after losing her Hawaiian trip, she lost me.
Thank you, xwiseguyx, for reminding about this event. I had forgotten she had done that to Libra. Plus Michelle is rough and rude enough to not be THAT likable. So I'm revising my rating to:
Michelle Costa: 4 out of 10
I was too generous before. I think that red unitard of hers hypnotized me a bit!
Here are my rankings which tend to fluctuate daily, especially when I spend way too much time watching Big Brother After Dark on Showtime.
1. Dan - 10/10 - He stays away from the screaming and shouting, seems very real, handled being America's Player with good humor, and seems like someone I'd hang out with in the real world. I hope he wins.
2. Renny - 7/10 - She annoyed the crap out of me at first, but she's grown on me. She cracks me up and isn't afraid to call people out when she's offended or crossed. She doesn't dwell on silly or inconsequential things and she isn't petty. She's a fun houseguest to watch.
3. Memphis - 6/10- Boring, but seems like a genuine guy. He stood up for Dan after the last vote when the houseguests were condemning him to hell(!) for casting a vote! (IT'S A GAME, JERRY! Dan shouldn't have to burn for all eternity for deceiving you!). He also does a good job of avoiding pointless shouting matches.
4. Libra - 5/10 - Yes, she shouts and has a temper, but watching her on late night has given me a new perspective of her. She's really not that bad. She seems like a nice person.
5. Keesha - 4/10 - I used to like her much more than this, but she's really gotten on my nerves lately. She can take the stupidest things and make them into huge issues. Seems like she NEEDS drama in her life.
6. Ollie 3/10 - Boring, but at least he doesn't scream at someone one minute then suck up to them the next. Props, too, for getting April to perform for the cameras late at night.
7. April 2/10 - Seeing her try to be BFFs with Michelle right now is ridiculous. She's too wishy washy and needy. April, I really don't think you're in love with Ollie and are going to marry him...
8. Michelle 1/10 - Psycho B***H! The only word in her vocabulary is the F word, which she uses for every part of speech - It's a noun, it's a verb, it's an adverb... She flies off the deep end about the most ridiculous things and has shown zero signs of sanity. I think she really believes she saw that banner.
9. Jerry - 0/10 - Worst. Houseguest. Ever. He defined hypocrite with the way he treated Dan after Dan's vote. Didn't Jerry do the EXACT SAME THING when he went back on his word in week one? He's calling Dan a Judas, condemning him to hell, screaming nonsense, sucking up to whomever is in power, going from group to group saying whatever he thinks they want to hear... He needs to go!
Posts: 264 | Location: Indiana | Registered: 10 January 2007
Originally posted by College Basketball Fan: 9. Jerry - 0/10 - Worst. Houseguest. Ever. He defined hypocrite with the way he treated Dan after Dan's vote. Didn't Jerry do the EXACT SAME THING when he went back on his word in week one? He's calling Dan a Judas, condemning him to hell, screaming nonsense, sucking up to whomever is in power, going from group to group saying whatever he thinks they want to hear... He needs to go!
Yeah, that was ridiculous last night. Taking shots at someone elses religion is uncalled for. He needs to go next for sure.
As for last week, Marc, Renny's comment may have been a bit inappropriate but considering Jessie's arrogance, Jessie deserved to be humbled. I had no problem with Renny's goodbye.
My ratings of the remaining residing houseguests, as of August 17, 2008 ("0" being most disliked by me; "10" being most liked by me):
Dan Gheesling: 9 out of 10 He's now like Dr. Will Kirby, sans me wanting to punch him in the face. I love it! Go Dan!
Renny Martyn: 8 out of 10 Winning Head of Household is just the cherry on top!
Keesha Smith: 6 out of 10 She's getting to be a little more whiny lately but this week, she should have no complaints. And, her disliking April Dowling is a big plus for me!
Memphis Garrett: 5 out of 10 Still boring. Yawn.
Michelle Costa: 4 out of 10 How about taking a joke, Michelle? If Dan really was America's Player for the entire season, why would he keep teasing you that he'd get $5,000 each time he does #2 in your HoH bathroom? Also meant to be a joke: Libra's comment that Keesha is only burying the hatchet with April just to get her designer dresses.
And now for the complete duds... STILL!:
Jerry MacDonald: 2 out of 10 The more you attack Dan, the more you go down in my book! You're another one who takes things too seriously.
April Dowling: 1 out of 10 This is what happens when you don't own up to anything and think you're better than you are or anyone else. Just count your days to the jury house. Don't worry - merely the fingers on your hands will do for counting!
Bryan Ollie aka "Ollie": 0 out of 10 He offers no original insight. In reference to the current Olympics, April is a gymnast and he is her pommel horse.
Renny - 8.5 out of 10: Can't wait to see her as HoH this week and her subsequent nominations which are bound to put two from the "dark side" on the block.
Dan - 8 out of 10: I only wish he'd spit back at Jerry when Jerry drivels.
Michelle - 7 out of 10: After last week, she's fallin' in the rankings and risin' on the bitch-o-meter!
Memphis - 5 out of 10: Somebody please wake this dude up and call him a womanizer already...
...And the bottom 4
Keesha - 2.5 out of 10 Her only redeeming quality (save for looks, of course) is that she hates April. Too much of a drama-queen.
April - 2 out of 10: Wasn't she aligned with Keesha at some point? Just checking. She sucks up to HoH every week and is more fake than professional wrestling.
Ollie - 1 out of 10: What is this guy gonna do when he and/or April gets evicted? Oh wait, don't answer that.
Jerry - 0 out of 10 And when I say zero, I mean negative two billion.
9/10: Renny- I've really loved watching her watch these idiots. She will be a great HOH. Dan- I really like this guy. Mostly for the America's player stuff but also for the fact that he really thinks he's done some tricky things when in reality its just that things have worked out for him. Memphis- His hatred for the annoying Jerry puts him up here alone. "Where I come from, these people would be shot!"
7/10: Libra (now evicted)- added a lot of fun drama.
5/10: Keesha- she gets the mute treatment for the same reasons the Pussy Catt Dolls Presents did. Michelle- this girl needs grammer lessons but is fun to watch due to the derangement she had when Jesse was around.
3/10: Ollie- this guy is a player if there ever was one. I'm sure pops is real proud.
0/10: Jerry- loved him at first- now I hate him- what a hypocrite.
Doug, here are my ratings: Dan - 8 - plays a clever game, not too annoying, may slip through till the end. Keesha - 7 - attractive girl, plays hard, competitive, not overly annoying. Michelle - 6 - so-so player, may hang around a bit longer; can be whining and annoying. Memphis - 5 - managing to stay alive, might be dangerous if allowed to get to the later stages. Renny - 4.5 - I don't care for her, although she is playing an increasingly smart game. She's HOH this week, but, soon her time will come for the old kick out of the house - I hope. Ollie - 4 - in my opinion, the most dangerous - I don't like him, but, his under-the-radar game may carry him far - hope not! April - 3 - conniving and annoying, but, a tough competitor - could be dangerous unless she gets the boot this upcoming week. Jerry - 2 - what is he doing on this show - increasingly annoying and should be going home soon for a long rest. Cranky without his nap. Libra - 0 - as of my post, she has already, thankfully, been kicked out - she should have gone sooner - confrontational, loud and obnoxious.
