Get the Flash Player to see this player.

Latest Headlines:
    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  PIFeedback Challenge  Hop To Forums  Play the PIFeedback Game    Game #1: 11/27/06 - 12/24/06 COMPLETED
Page 1 2 3 4 5 
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
-star Rating Rate It!  Login/Join 
Picture of Douglas
Posted
A few years ago, the Billboard.com website used to have an online game called "Billboard Challenge" which asks users to pick 10 albums and see how they fared in a 4-week period. Back in 2000, I actually won this contest and received a prize... of Billboard information CD-ROM! So it wasn't a great prize but a prize nonetheless.

Well, I'll introduce such a game here and see how it goes. Here are the rules:

1. You pick 5 shows:
a. Only one (1) show from last week's programs, ranking 1-20.
b. Only one (1) show from last week's programs, ranking 21-40.
c. Only three (3) shows from last week's programs, ranking 41-last place but at least one (1) show has to come from The CW and at least one (1) show has to come from Univision (UNI).

Note: If you're picking a telenovela from Univision or any network show that airs on more than one day and/or timeslot, indicate the specific day and timeslot you're picking - for example, "La Fea Mas Bella" Tuesday and "La Fea Mas Bella" Wednesday are 2 different shows in this game; another example, "Bones" at 8 p.m. is a different show than "Bones" at 9 p.m.



2. You'll obtain points as follows:
a. The list the game will refer to will be the weekly most-watched primetime shows at the L.A. Times website (http://www.calendarlive.com/tv/)
b. The points for your chosen show each week will use this formula:

(Number of primetime programs + 1) - (Rank position of your show)

For example, if the site publishes the top 100 primetime programs of the week, you choose "Desperate Housewives" this week and it ranks #1 in a week during the 4-week period of the game, you'll get 100 points for that week [ (100+1) - 1 = 100 ]

I won't count any shows from Telemundo (TEL), MyNetworkTV (MNT), and of course, any basic cable shows but I will count shows from Univision (UNI).

So for the week of November 13-19, 2006, there are only 124 TV programs to choose from (Reference: http://www.calendarlive.com/tv/cl-et-tvratingstext22nov....story?coll=cl-tvent). You'll start to obtain points in 2 weeks, starting from the November 27-December 3, 2006 list. Here are the top shows of (Nov. 13-19) to choose from:

1 Dancing With the Stars Results ABC 27.51
2 Dancing With the Stars ABC 26.80
3 CSI CBS 24.11
4 "NFL Post-Game" CBS 23.76
5 Desperate Housewives ABC 21.63

6 Grey's Anatomy (Thu.) ABC 20.92
7 60 Minutes CBS 19.16
8 CSI: Miami CBS 18.76
9 Deal or No Deal (Mon.) NBC 18.07
10 Criminal Minds CBS 16.47

11 CSI: NY CBS 16.18
12 Two and a Half Men CBS 15.83
13 NCIS CBS 15.80
14 Survivor: Cook Islands CBS 15.35
15 Extreme Makeover:Home Edition ABC 15.31

16 Shark CBS 15.24
17 Heroes NBC 15.08
18 Sunday Night Football NBC 14.99
19 Law & Order: SVU (Tue.) NBC 14.76
20 House (Tue.) FOX 14.60
-----------------------------------------------
21 Cold Case CBS 14.53
22 Without a Trace CBS 14.51
23 Brothers & Sisters ABC 13.04
24 Ugly Betty ABC 12.95
25 "Barbara Walters Special" (Thu.) ABC 12.91

26 Deal or No Deal (Fri.) NBC 12.67
27 E.R. NBC 12.52
28 Amazing Race 10 CBS 12.40
29 Show Me the Money ABC 12.39
30 Old Christine CBS 11.87

31 The Unit CBS 11.84
32 Numb3rs CBS 10.73
33 America's FunniestHome Videos ABC 10.58
34 Close to Home CBS 10.56
35 Day Break ABC 10.16

36 Ghost Whisperer CBS 10.13
37 Law & Order NBC 9.94
38 3 Lbs. CBS 9.86
39 NFL Pre-Game NBC 9.50
40 Medium NBC 9.44
-----------------------------------------------
41 Jericho CBS 9.34
42 How I Met Your Mother CBS 9.33
43 "Barbara Walters Special" (Fri.) ABC 9.31
44 Family Guy FOX 9.30
45 The Simpsons (8 p.m.) FOX 9.27

46 College Football ABC 9.23
47 Prison Break FOX 9.21
48 House (Fri.) FOX 9.17
49 Law & Order:Criminal Intent NBC 9.14
50 My Name Is Earl NBC 9.11

51 Las Vegas NBC 9.04
52 The Class CBS 8.44
53 The Office NBC 8.43
54 Bachelor: Rome ABC 8.35
55 American Dad(8:30 p.m.) FOX 8.24

56 Football Night in America, Part 3 NBC 8.00
57 Bones (8 p.m.) FOX 7.83
58 48 Hours Mystery CBS 7.58
58 Studio 60 on Sunset Strip NBC 7.58
60 20/20 ABC 7.48

61 Law & Order: SVU (Sat.) NBC 7.41
62 Crimetime Saturday(9 p.m.) CBS 7.32
63 College Football Pre-Game ABC 6.93
64 Crimetime Saturday(8 p.m.) CBS 6.92
65 Football Night in America, Part 2 NBC 6.79

66 War at Home FOX 6.63
67 Wife Swap ABC 6.54
68 Biggest Loser NBC 6.37
69 America's Most Wanted FOX 5.99
70 Bones (9 p.m.) FOX 5.77

71 The Simpsons(7:30 p.m.) FOX 5.70
72 Grey's Anatomy (Fri.) ABC 5.68
73 Cops (8:30 p.m.) FOX 5.60
74 Friday Night Lights NBC 5.48
75 La Fea Más Bella (Mon.) UNI 5.27

76 What About Brian ABC 5.21
77 30 Rock NBC 5.19
78 La Fea Más Bella (Thu.) UNI 5.08
79 La Fea Más Bella (Wed.) UNI 5.06
80 La Fea Más Bella (Tue.) UNI 5.03

81 Dateline: NBC (Sat.) NBC 4.95
82 Cops (8 p.m.) FOX 4.82
83 America's Next Top Model (Wed.) CW 4.71
84 Smallville CW 4.70
85 La Fea Más Bella (Fri.) UNI 4.65

86 Standoff FOX 4.64
87 Til Death (8 p.m.) FOX 4.55
88 Til Death (8:30 p.m.) FOX 4.54
89 Gilmore Girls CW 4.51
89 7th Heaven CW 4.51

91 Reba (7:30 p.m.) CW 4.34
92 Friday Night Smackdown! CW 4.21
93 Don Francisco Presenta UNI 3.82
94 Trading Spouses (9 p.m.) FOX 3.78
95 The O.C. FOX 3.77

96 American Dad (7 p.m.) FOX 3.68
96 Reba (7 p.m.) CW 3.68
98 Mundo de Fieras (Mon.) UNI 3.63
99 Mundo de Fieras (Wed.) UNI 3.54
100 Mundo de Fieras (Thu.) UNI 3.40

101 Mundo de Fieras (Fri.) UNI 3.38
102 Trading Spouses (8 p.m.) FOX 3.28
103 Mundo de Fieras (Tue.) UNI 3.25
104 Everybody Hates Chris CW 3.22
105 Heridas de Amor (Wed.) UNI 3.21

106 Supernatural CW 3.16
107 One Tree Hill CW 3.15
108 All of Us CW 3.10
109 Heridas de Amor (Thu.) UNI 3.04
110 Heridas de Amor (Tue.) UNI 3.00

110 Heridas de Amor (Mon.) UNI 3.00
112 Girlfriends CW 2.98
113 Aqui y Ahora (Thu.) UNI 2.70
114 Veronica Mars CW 2.69
115 Reyes de la Canción UNI 2.67

116 Cristina UNI 2.58
117 "25 Años:Noticiero Univision" UNI 2.57
117 Heridas de Amor (Fri.) UNI 2.57
119 The Game CW 2.43
120 Hora Pico UNI 2.38

121 Sabado Gigante UNI 2.25
122 Ver Para Creer UNI 2.12
123 Casos Familia UNI 1.88
124 America's Top Model (Sun.) CW 1.83

(Why give the L.A. Times website any more traffic - this PI Feedback site's the place to be! Big Grin)

3. You can have similar shows on your roster than other players but you can't copy the exact 5 shows from another player.



4. You can post as many comment and discussion posts as you want in this thread but you can only post your roster of shows once, so think carefully before posting.



5. This particular game will last 4 weeks from November 27 to December 24 - winner of this game will know if they win on December 28, 2006. If this is a somewhat successful thread, I can start another overlapping game on another thread next week so another 4-week game can start December 4 and the winner of that game will be announced on January 4, 2007.



Deadline: Monday, November 27, 2006 6:59p.m. ET

This message has been edited. Last edited by: Douglas,
 
Posts: 3691 | Registered: 20 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Douglas
Posted Hide Post
Here are my 5 shows (with rankings from November 13-19, 2006, included):

18. Sunday Night Football (NBC, Sundays 8:21p.m.)
32. Numb3rs (CBS, Fridays 10:00p.m.)
44. Family Guy (FOX, Sundays 9:00p.m.)
78. La Fea Más Bella (UNI, Thursdays 8:00p.m.)
91. Reba (CW, Sundays 7:30p.m.)
 
Posts: 3691 | Registered: 20 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Marc Berman
Posted Hide Post
What a great idea! Here are my five picks:

10. Criminal Minds (CBS, Wed. 9 p.m.)
28. The Amazing Race 10 (CBS, Sun. 8 p.m.)
47. Prison Break (Fox, Mon. 8 p.m.)
89(t). 7th Heaven (CW, Sun. 8 p.m.)
93. Don Francisco Presenta (UNI, not sure when it airs)


 
Posts: 8264 | Registered: 18 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of TravisYanan
Posted Hide Post
3. CSI (CBS, Thursday, 9pm)
22. Without A Trace (CBS, Sunday, 10pm)
49. Law & Order: Criminal Intent (NBC, Tuesday, 9pm)
75. La Fea Mas Bella (Uni, Monday, 8pm)
83. America's Next Top Model (CW, Wednesday, 8pm)
 
Posts: 3555 | Location: Los Angeles | Registered: 21 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of starbase135
Posted Hide Post
17. Heroes (NBC, Monday, 9pm)
28. The Amazing Race 10 (CBS, Sunday, 8pm)
47. Prison Break (FOX, Monday, 8pm)
75. La Fea Más Bella (UNI, Monday, 8pm)
83. America's Next Top Model (The CW, Wednesday, 8pm)
 
Posts: 372 | Registered: 29 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of healingbuddy
Posted Hide Post
6. Grey's Anatomy(ABC, Thursday, 9PM)
23. Brothers & Sisters(ABC, Sunday, 10PM)
67. Wife Swap(ABC, Monday ,8PM)
75. La Fea Bella(UNI, Monday, 8PM)
89. 7th Heaven(CW, Sunday, 8PM)

This message has been edited. Last edited by: healingbuddy,
 
Posts: 414 | Location: Hoboken, NJ | Registered: 06 November 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
15 Extreme Makeover:Home Edition (ABC, Sunday 8PM)
32 Numb3rs (CBS, Friday 10PM)
42 How I Met Your Mother (CBS, Monday 8PM)
75. La Fea Bella(UNI, Monday, 8PM)
89. 7th Heaven(CW, Sunday, 8PM)


Start Here

 
Posts: 2631 | Registered: 20 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
3. CSI (CBS Thursday 9:00 pm)
21. Cold Case (CBS Sunday 9:00 pm)
42. How I Met Your Mother (CBS Monday 8:00 pm)
75. La Fea Mas Bella (UNI Monday 8:00 pm)
84. Smallville (CW Thursday 8:00 pm)
 
Posts: 182 | Registered: 06 November 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Douglas
Posted Hide Post
Thanks for the response! I didn't think this would get any responses but glad there's more than just myself as a participant!

I remembered from the old Billboard Challenge game that there were bonus points awarded for such things as the "Greatest Gainer". Also, there were variations on which albums to choose from - so using our game as an example, you can choose all 5 of your shows that ranked 41 and below.

These extra incentives for points might have been too complicated, which is why I wanted to keep the instructions as simple as I could to kick this game off. However, since there is some interest here, I'll implement these extra features at the start of the next game (which starts this Wednesday). Here's what to expect:

- Bonus points for being the most-watched show of its night
- Bonus points for being the most-watched show of its network
(Don't know how many bonus points yet - please suggest!)

Also, you can choose 5 shows using one of the following scenarios (all of them would have to include 1 show of CW and 1 show of UNI):
- 1 show from 1-20, 1 show from 21-40, 3 shows from 41-last
- 2 shows from 21-40, 3 shows from 41-last
- 1 show from 1-40, 4 shows from 41-last
- 5 shows from 41-last

And finally, if you notice, the deadline of submission correlates to one minute before the start of the week of primetime shows, according to the list we use.

Once again, thanks for all the participation!
 
Posts: 3691 | Registered: 20 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
9. Deal Or No Deal (NBC, Monday 8:00)
29. Show Me The Money (ABC, Wednesday 8:00)
49. Law & Order: Criminal Intent (NBC, Tue 9:00)
75. La Fea Mas Bella (UNI, Thursday)
83. America's Next Top Model (CW, Wed 8:00)
 
Posts: 331 | Location: Los Angeles, CA | Registered: 27 October 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
3. CSI (CBS Thursday 9:00 pm)
27. ER (CBS Thursday 10:00 pm)
42. How I Met Your Mother (CBS Monday 8:00 pm)
75. La Fea Más Bella (UNI Monday 8:00 pm)
83. America's Next Top Model (The CW Wednesday 8:00 pm)
 
Posts: 234 | Registered: 11 October 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of TheCWFan
Posted Hide Post
can someone explain it to me? i dont get it Frowner



The CW Television Network Presents: Gossip Girl
Premieres Wed. Sept 26th at 9/8c after Top Model
 
Posts: 701 | Location: Texas | Registered: 20 November 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of Douglas
Posted Hide Post
quote:
Originally posted by TheCWFan:
can someone explain it to me? i dont get it Frowner



Yeah, sure.

You basically pick 5 shows from the most current week's list of most-watched programs, which are found here: http://www.calendarlive.com/tv/cl-et-tvratingstext22nov....story?coll=cl-tvent

Obviously, it would be unfair to pick the top 5 shows as your roster of 5 - there are limits - so among your 5, you have to choose a CW show (no problem for you Wink) and a show from Univision. Refer to the very first post of this thread for more detailed instructions.

In 2 weeks, you'll start to acquire points for each show you pick on how it'll do in the coming weeks. Why 2 weeks and not this week? I can't start implementing it for this week because you could find out how each show has done among viewers this past week from the Overnights in this forum.

Explaining the point system in detail might confuse you even more, but let's say that you will do as well in this game as your chosen shows will do in its viewer numbers.

If you're wondering how I came up with this whole game, I also mention the influence in the first post of the thread.

If any more questions, feel free to ask.
 
Posts: 3691 | Registered: 20 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
Great idea! I remember the old Billboard games. Thanks for setting this up!

3. CSI (CBS, Thursday 9:00)
40. Medium (NBC, Wed. 10:00)
49. L&O CI (NBC, Tuesday 9:00)
79. La Fea Men Bella (UNI Wed.)
91. Reba (CW, Sunday, 7:30 p.m.)
 
Posts: 111 | Registered: 10 November 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
Picture of xwiseguyx
Posted Hide Post
14 Survivor: Cook Islands
28 Amazing Race 10
77 30 Rock
93 Don Francisco Presenta
91 Reba (7:30 p.m.)

I guess what I don't understand is what happens when a show is pre-empted or do we get to choose new shows each week?


====================
 
Posts: 5958 | Location: Chicago, IL | Registered: 20 September 2006Reply With QuoteEdit or Delete MessageReport This Post
 Previous Topic | Next Topic powered by eve community Page 1 2 3 4 5  
 

    Forums  Hop To Forum Categories  PIFeedback Challenge  Hop To Forums  Play the PIFeedback Game    Game #1: 11/27/06 - 12/24/06 COMPLETED