Comedies: Aliens, Big Bang, and Back to You are all very highly regarded. The lowest-rated fall comedy is neither Cavemen (3 thumbs up, 9 down) nor Carpoolers (2 up, 9 down) but in fact Samantha Who (2 up, 10 down). Surprising. Cavemen reaction was negative, but not universally so, which is about what I would expect.
Dramas: I thought Pushing and Reaper were the two best pilots I saw, so no real surprise there (though I'm worried about the quality holding up in both cases). For me, the only real surprise is Big Shots, which I didn't expect to rate so well.
Originally posted by TV-aholic: Not a good sign for Moonlight that only One critic saw the pilot. CBS must be keeping this under wraps
I think there's been a ton of reshooting and stuff there, so it may not be ready yet (maybe the one guy who saw it saw an early version). I don't think the Brothers and Sisters pilot was finished at this time last year, though I could be wrong.
Go ahead, but I'll still say that a new procedural like the Man is their best shot at success on Tuesday at 10 or even better moving the overrated the Unit back an hour and try something new, Jericho, or the Amazing Race at 9 on Tuesday. The 3 and done club is calling.
quote:
Originally posted by TV-aholic: I take a critics opinion with a grain of salt. Their opinion is about as useful as my dead cat's
quote:
Originally posted by mushu_jj: Now does everyone believe me about Cane?
Go ahead, but I'll still say that a new procedural like the Man is their best shot at success on Tuesday at 10 or even better moving the overrated the Unit back an hour and try something new, Jericho, or the Amazing Race at 9 on Tuesday. The 3 and done club is calling.
Jericho??? It couldn't attract viewers if they PAID them. The Unit may be the weakest show in the CBS Fall Schedule. And why would you schedule Amazing Race against American Idol??
